Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
loxcane

Baseball ATD I Draft Thread

Recommended Posts

Make all your picks here, keep the discussion to the other thread so this stays relatively well organized. You're drafting a full 25 man roster and one manager. How you choose to build that in terms of numbers of starters, relievers and bench players is up to you. Keep your rosters updated in the roster thread, when I make one of those and choose a team name, which I'll eventually include in here... but not right now cause I'm really lazy. Order is going to snake, so I'll include the first two rounds below to begin with. Time limit is 12 hours and runs 24 hours a day so if you're not going to be here for 12 hours leave a list. If you miss your pick you can make it up when you do return, if it gets to the point where we need to fill out the picks you've missed we'll use highest WAR available at a position empty in your roster.

 

Here's the order, bitches...

 

Round 1

1. Victorqvist - OF/SP - George "Babe" Ruth

2. Morrison7 - OF - Willie Mays

3. TieClark - OF - Hank Aaron

4. HIPPYHAPPY - OF - Ty Cobb

5. The Batman - OF - Ted Williams

6. Sandman - SS - Honus Wagner

7. The Leaf - SP - Pete "Grover" Alexander

8. loxcane - SP, Walter Johnson

9. the can opener - 2B - Rogers Hornsby

10. majingir - SP, Cy Young

 

Round 2

11. majingir - 1B, Lou Gehrig

12. the can opener - SP - Greg Maddux

13. loxcane - SP - Robert "Lefty" Grove

14. The Leaf - OF - Tris Speaker

15. Sandman - OF/1B - Stan Musial

16. The Batman - SP - Christy Mathewson

17. HIPPYHAPPY - SP - Tom Seaver

18. TieClark - OF - Mickey Mantle

19. Morrison7 - SP - Sandy Koufax

20. Victorqvist - OF - Joe DiMaggio

 

Round 3

21. Victorqvist - SP - Randy Johnson

22. Morrison7 - SP - Pedro Martinez

23. TieClark - SP - Roger Clemens

24. HIPPYHAPPY - 1B - Jimmie Foxx

25. The Batman - 3B - Mike Schmidt

26. Sandman - 2B - Nap Lajoie

27. The Leaf - SP - Warren Spahn

28. loxcane - C - Johnny Bench

29. the can opener - OF - Barry Bonds

30. majingir - 2B - Eddie Collins

 

Round 4

31. majingir - SP - Steve Carlton

32. the can opener - OF - Oscar Charleston

33. loxcane - SP/RP - Satchel Paige

34. The Leaf - SP - Kid Nichols

35. Sandman - SP - Bob Gibson

36. The Batman - OF - Frank Robinson

37. HIPPYHAPPY - 2B/3B - Frankie Frisch

38. TieClark - 2B/1B/OF - Pete Rose

39. Morrison7 - OF - Carl Yastrzemski

40. Victorqvist - SP - Nolan Ryan

 

Round 5

41. Victorqvist - C - Yogi Berra

42. Morrison7 - 3B - Brooks Robinson

43. TieClark - 2B/1B - Jackie Robinson

44. HIPPYHAPPY - 1B/3B - Eddie Matthews

45. The Batman - SP - Bob Feller

46. Sandman - SP - Whitey Ford

47. The Leaf - 2B - Charlie Gehringer

48. loxcane - OF - Roberto Clemente

49. the can opener - C - Josh Gibson

50. majingir - OF - Mel Ott

 

Round 6

51. majingir - SP - Clayton Kershaw

52. the can opener - SP - Phil Niekro

53. loxcane - OF - Rickey Henderson

54. The Leaf - 3B - George Brett

55. Sandman - OF - Ken Griffey Jr.

56. The Batman - 2B - Joe Morgan

57. HIPPYHAPPY - SP - Carl Hubbell

58. TieClark - C - Roy Campanella

59. Morrison7 - SP - Jim Palmer

60. Victorqvist - 3B/SS - Alex Rodriguez

 

Round 7

61. Victorqvist - SP - Juan Marichal

62. Morrison7 - 1B - Mark McGwire

63. TieClark - 1B - George Sisler

64. HIPPYHAPPY - SS/1B - Ernie Banks

65. The Batman - SS/2B - John Henry Lloyd

66. Sandman - 1B - Hank Greenberg

67. The Leaf - SS - Cal Ripken Jr.

68. loxcane - SP - Tom Glavine

69. the can opener - 1B - Albert Pujols

70. majingir - RP - Mariano Rivera

 

Round 8

71. majingir - C - Mickey Cochrane

72. the can opener - SS - Arky Vaughan

73. loxcane - 3B - John Franklin "Home Run" Baker

74. The Leaf - SP - Ed Walsh

75. Sandman - SP - Mordecai Brown

76. The Batman - OF - Duke Snider

77. HIPPYHAPPY - OF - Lou Brock

78. TieClark - SP - Gaylord Perry

79. Morrison7 - 1B/3B/OF - Harmon Killebrew

80. Victorqvist - SP - "Smokey Joe" Williams

 

Round 9

81. Victorqvist - OF - Al Kaline

82. Morrison7 - SS - Robin Yount

83. TieClark - SP - Robin Roberts

84. HIPPYHAPPY - SP - Eddie Plank

85. The Leaf (from The Batman) - OF - James Thomas "Cool Papa" Bell

86. Sandman - OF - "Shoeless Joe" Jackson

87. The Batman (from The Leaf) -SP - Rube Waddell

88. loxcane - OF - Billy Hamilton

89. the can opener - 3B - Wade Boggs

90. majingir - SS - Derek Jeter

 

Round 10

91. majingir - OF - Kirby Puckett

92. the can opener - SP - Bert Blyleven

93. loxcane - SP/RP - John Smoltz

94. The Batman (from The Leaf) - SP - Ferguson Jenkins

95. Sandman - SP - Dizzy Dean

96. The Batman - 1B - Dan Brouthers

97. HIPPYHAPPY - C - Charles "Gabby" Hartnett

98. TieClark - OF - Tony Gwynn

99. Morrison7 - OF - Reggie Jackson

100. Victorqvist - 3B - Chipper Jones

 

Round 11

101. Victorqvist - SP - Don Drysdale

102. Morrison7 - 2B/1B - Rod Carew

103. TieClark - RP/SP - Dennis Eckersley

104. HIPPYHAPPY - SP - Early Wynn

105. The Leaf (from The Batman) - OF - Ichiro Suzuki

106. Sandman - C - Ivan "Pudge" Rodriguez

107. The Leaf - C - Carlton Fisk

108. loxcane - 2B - Roberto Alomar

109. the can opener - OF - Sam Crawford

110. majingir - OF - Al Simmons

 

Round 12

111. majingir - 1B/3B/OF - Miguel Cabrera

112. the can opener - SP/OF - John Clarkson

113. loxcane - SS - Ozzie Smith

114. The Leaf - SP - James Augustus "Catfish" Hunter

115. Sandman - SP - Hal Newhouser

116. The Batman - SP - Don Sutton

117. HIPPYHAPPY - OF - Harry Heilmann

118. Tie Clark - SS - Joe Cronin

119. Morrison7 - C - Mike Piazza

120. Victorqvist - 1B - Adrian "Cap" Anson

 

Round 13

121. Victorqvist - RP - Rich "Goose" Gossage

122. Morrison7 - RP - Rollie Fingers

123. TieClark - SP - Roy Halladay

124. HIPPYHAPPY - SP - Jim Bunning

125. The Batman - 1B - Frank Thomas

126. Sandman - 3B - Scott Rolen

127. The Leaf - RP - Hoyt Wilhelm

128. loxcane - 1B - Johnny Mize

129. the can opener - RP - Bruce Sutter

130. majingir - 1B/DH/3B - Jim Thome

 

Round 14

131. majingir - SP - Curt Schilling

132. the can opener - RP - Dan Quisenberry

133. loxcane - RP - Trevor Hoffman

134. The Leaf - RP - Billy Wagner

135. Sandman - 3B - Ron Santo

136. The Batman - RP - Lee Smith

137. HIPPYHAPPY - RP - Sparky Lyle

138. Tie Clark - SP - Leon Day

139. Morrison7 - DH/3B/2B - Paul Molitor

140. Victorqvist - RP - Jonathan Papelbon

 

Round 15

141. Victorqvist - OF - Vladimir Guerrero

142. Morrison7 - SP/OF - James "Pud" Galvin

143. TieClark - 1B - Walter "Buck" Leonard

144. HIPPYHAPPY - 2B/1B - Derrill "Del" Pratt

145. The Batman - 1B - Willie McCovey

146. Sandman - RP - John Franco

147. The Leaf - 1B - Eddie Murray

148. loxcane - OF - Manny Ramirez

149. the can opener - OF - Dave Winfield

150. majingir - SP - Mike Mussina

 

Round 16

151. majingir - OF - Tim Raines

152. the can opener - SP - Tim Keefe

153. loxcane - RP - Mike Marshall

154. The Leaf - RP - Frank Edwin "Tug" McGraw

155. Sandman - RP - Huston Street

156. The Batman - RP - Tom Henke

157. HIPPYHAPPY - RP - Robb Nen

158. Tie Clark - RP - Joe Nathan

159. Morrison7 - OF - Mike Trout

160. Victorqvist - 2B - Ryan Sandberg

 

Round 17

161. Victorqvist - RP - Jeff Reardon

162. Morrison7 - SP - Felix Hernandez

163. TieClark - RP - Duane Ward

164. HIPPYHAPPY - RP - John Wetteland

165. The Batman - C - Billy Dickey

166. Sandman - 2B/C/OF - Craig Biggio

167. The Leaf - 3B/C/OF - Deacon White

168. loxcane - RP/SP - Firpo Marberry

169. the can opener - SP - Billy Pierce

170. majingir - C - Gary Carter

 

Round 18

171. majingir - 1B - Jeff Bagwell

172. the can opener - OF/1B - Willie Stargell

173. loxcane - OF/1B/2B - Ed Delehanty

174. The Leaf - OF/1B - Harry Stovey

175. Sandman - P/OF - Charles Gardner "Old Hoss" Radbourn

176. The Batman - 1B - Jim Bottomley

177. HIPPYHAPPY - 3B - Stan Hack

178. Tie Clark - RP - Jose Mesa

179. Morrison7 - SP - Jim McCormick

180. Victorqvist - OF/1B - Larry Walker

 

Round 19

181. Victorqvist - SS - Alan Trammell

182. Morrison7 - OF - Andre Dawson

183. TieClark - 1B/OF - Don Mattingly

184. HIPPYHAPPY - RP - Dick Radatz

185. The Batman - RP - Kent Tekulve

186. Sandman - OF/1B - Monte Irvin

187. The Leaf - RP - Francisco Rodriguez

188. loxcane - SS - Barry Larkin

189. the can opener - 2B/3B/1B - Jeff Kent

190. majingir - RP - Aroldis Chapman

 

Round 20

191. majingir - RP - Craig Kimbrel

192. the can opener - C - Thurman Munson

193. loxcane - RP - Jesse Orosco

194. The Leaf - SS/3B - Harold Henry "Pee Wee" Reese

195. Sandman - RP - Lindy McDaniel

196. The Batman - RP - Rod Beck

197. HIPPYHAPPY - RP - Rick Aguilera

198. Tie Clark - RP - LaTroy Hawkins

199. Morrison7 - RP - Michael Jackson

200. Victorqvist - RP - Dave Righetti

 

Round 21

201. Victorqvist - C - Joe Torre

202. Morrison7 - RP - Jeff Montgomery

203. TieClark - SP - Jack Morris

204. HIPPYHAPPY - C/1B/LF - Elston Howard

205. The Batman - SP - Eddie Cicotte

206. Sandman - SP/RP - Ellis Kinder

207. The Leaf - RP - Charles Albert "Chief" Bender

208. loxcane - RP - Randy Myers

209. the can opener - SP - Jim Kaat

210. majingir - RP - John Hiller

 

Round 22

211. majingir - RP - Greg Holland

212. the can opener - SP/OF - Charles Wilber "Bullet" Rogan

213. loxcane - 3B - Pie Traynor

214. The Leaf - RP - Troy Percival

215. Sandman - OF/1B - Billy Williams

216. The Batman - OF - Sam Thompson

217. HIPPYHAPPY - OF/P - Bob Caruthers

218. Tie Clark - C - Jorge Posada

219. Morrison7 - OF - Bernie Williams

220. Victorqvist - SP - Johan Santana

 

Round 23

221. Victorqvist - RP - Ted Abernathy

222. Morrison7 - OF/DH/1B - Jason Giambi

223. TieClark - 1B/OF - Rafael Palmeiro

224. HIPPYHAPPY - SS/3B - Vern Stephens

225. The Batman - Manager - Joe McCarthy

226. Sandman - RP - Bobby Shantz

227. The Leaf - OF - Sammy Sosa

228. loxcane - C - Jason Varitek

229. the can opener - OF - Fred Lynn

230. majingir - RP - Kenley Jansen

 

Round 24

231. majingir - SS/3B - Omar Vizquel

232. the can opener - SP - Andy Pettitte

233. loxcane - SP - Addie Joss

234. The Leaf - RP - Mark Eichorn

235. Sandman - 3B/2B - Ray Dandridge

236. The Batman - RP - Rafael Soriano

237. HIPPYHAPPY - SP - Vic Willis

238. Tie Clark - 3B - Judy Johnson

239. Morrison7 - SP - Jack Chesbro

240. Victorqvist - Manager - Sparky Anderson

 

Round 25

241. Victorqvist - OF - Dale Murphy

242. Morrison7 - SP/OF - Clark Griffith

243. TieClark - SP - Dave Stieb

244. HIPPYHAPPY - Manager - John McGraw

245. The Batman - Manager - Buck Ewing

246. Sandman - Manager - Casey Stengel

247. The Leaf - OF - Paul Waner

248. loxcane - SP - Lefty Gomez

249. the can opener - Manager - Earl Weaver

250. majingir - Manager - Joe Torre

 

Round 26

251. majingir - SP - Dazzy Vance

252. the can opener - SP - John Donaldson

253. loxcane - Manager - Bobby Cox

254. The Leaf - Manager - Connie Mack

255. Sandman - SP/RP - Tom Gordon

256. The Batman - SP - Ed Reulbach

257. HIPPYHAPPY - OF/3B/SS - Gary Sheffield

258. Tie Clark - Manager - Tommy Lasorda

259. Morrison7 - Manager - Walter Alston

260. Victorqvist - RP - Elroy Face

 

@@Victorqvist you could stop bugging me now and pick

Edited by Victorqvist

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We got 10 rounds, I'm just hoping I can build a much better team this time around compared to last time.

Like I said it's an okay pick but for example you left Ty Cobb on the table who I could make a very strong argument for as the best player to ever play.  Still, Mays is obviously a great player so it shouldn't hurt you at all - this is just my opinion btw..  There some serious steals later on especially if people pick guys like Hank Aaron number 3.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the most part, positional players are fairly consistent through all the rankings.  There are some real oddballs ones out there but that's what you get with the mainstream.  The best and most fun part is people picking pitchers.  The mainstream lists are all over the damn place so it's a lot of fun in my mind to see what unfolds.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...